Catholic IntelligenceToday in the Church's year →
Search
If the Lord does not watch over the city, in vain does the watchman keep vigil.Ps 127:1

Bishops

Bishop Robert Barron criticizes Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco

First source report

Catholic IntelligenceUpdated 1 min read

Bishop Robert Barron of the Diocese of Winona-Rochester criticized Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco regarding the mission of the Church to convert others. In a post on X, Barron described the claim that the Church is not there to convert as disconcerting. He stated that if he believed the Church did not exist to bring people to Christ, he would resign his office and seek honest work.

The criticism followed an interview with CathoBel, in which Cardinal Vesco said the Church should not be proselytizing but should instead participate in society through fraternity and coexistence.

Reports from CathoBel indicate that the statements used in the criticism were inaccurate. The outlet noted that the first quotation regarding the Church's call to conversion was taken out of context. Furthermore, a second quotation attributed to the cardinal was never spoken by him, but instead originated from a summary written by Ad Vaticanum.

AI-assisted briefing based on the sources below.

5 sources3 languages

Read it in Español · Français · English

Read the source

Sources behind this story

More on Jean-Paul Vesco

  1. Oct 29, 5:39 PM PT · 3 sources Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco rejects conversion-oriented Church
  2. Aug 24, 10:56 AM PT Cardinal Vesco calls Augustine a universal brother
  3. Aug 24, 4:18 AM PT · 2 sources Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco prefers running to Mass
  4. Aug 16, 10:00 PM PT Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco preaches unity at Lourdes

More coverage of Jean-Paul Vesco

More Catholic news

Earlier version, Thursday 29 October

Bishop Robert Barron responds to Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco

How the coverage unfolded

  1. Oct 29, 4:25 AM InfoVaticana Español Barron responde al cardenal Vesco: «Si pensara que la Iglesia no existe para llevar a la gente a Cristo, dimitiría»
  2. Oct 29, 9:58 AM InfoCatólica Español Mons. Barron responde al cardenal Vesco
  3. Oct 29, 11:11 AM CathoBel Français Mgr Robert Barron s’en prend au cardinal Vesco sur la conversion : mais qu’a vraiment dit le cardinal ?
  4. Oct 29, 12:00 PM Crisis Point Bishop Barron Fires Back at a Cardinal: "Excuse Me, but…What?"
  5. Oct 29, 6:02 PM Where Peter Is Cardinal Vesco’s Words Were Taken Out of Context

More on Jean-Paul Vesco

  1. Oct 29, 5:39 PM PT · 3 sources Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco rejects conversion-oriented Church
  2. Aug 24, 10:56 AM PT Cardinal Vesco calls Augustine a universal brother
  3. Aug 24, 4:18 AM PT · 2 sources Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco prefers running to Mass
  4. Aug 16, 10:00 PM PT Cardinal Jean-Paul Vesco preaches unity at Lourdes

More coverage of Jean-Paul Vesco

Discussion

Loading discussion…

Catholic News · Comments are signed by readers with a verified address.